are trying to debug a "broadband" setup (because your LAN setup will be "debugged" before you even try adding "broadband" into the mix)! One way to accomplish this, is to buy or build a "router" with "NAT" (Network Address Translation) ability, that knows how to work with an external modem (as well as the more "normal" broadband/ethernet connection). If your LAN is "small enough" (5 machines max using the internet), and
Rew dial up services, Rew, PA up services dial Rew
Rew up services, dial Pennsylvania, Rew dial up services